What is the difference between using HTTParty as a module vs as a class?

HTTParty is a popular Ruby gem that simplifies making HTTP requests and is widely used for web scraping and API consumption. One of the key design decisions when using HTTParty is whether to include it as a module or inherit from it as a class. Each approach has distinct advantages, use cases, and implications for your code architecture.

Understanding HTTParty Integration Methods

HTTParty can be integrated into your Ruby code in two primary ways:

As a Module: Including HTTParty functionality into your existing classes
As a Class: Inheriting from HTTParty to create specialized HTTP client classes

Let's explore both approaches in detail with practical examples and considerations.

Using HTTParty as a Module

When you include HTTParty as a module, you're adding its functionality to an existing class without changing the inheritance hierarchy. This is done using Ruby's include keyword.

Basic Module Usage

require 'httparty'

class ApiClient
  include HTTParty

  base_uri 'https://api.example.com'
  default_timeout 30

  def initialize(api_key)
    @api_key = api_key
    self.class.headers 'Authorization' => "Bearer #{@api_key}"
  end

  def fetch_user(user_id)
    self.class.get("/users/#{user_id}")
  end

  def create_user(user_data)
    self.class.post('/users', body: user_data.to_json, 
                    headers: { 'Content-Type' => 'application/json' })
  end
end

# Usage
client = ApiClient.new('your-api-key')
response = client.fetch_user(123)

Module Approach Characteristics

Advantages: - Flexible inheritance: Your class can inherit from other classes while still using HTTParty - Composition over inheritance: Follows the principle of favoring composition - Multiple concerns: Your class can handle both HTTP operations and other business logic - Instance-level configuration: Each instance can have different configurations

Disadvantages: - Method access: You need to use self.class to access HTTParty methods - Slightly more verbose: Requires explicit class method calls - Configuration scope: Base URI and headers are set at the class level

Using HTTParty as a Class

When you inherit from HTTParty, your class becomes a specialized HTTP client with direct access to all HTTParty methods.

Basic Class Inheritance

require 'httparty'

class UserService < HTTParty
  base_uri 'https://jsonplaceholder.typicode.com'
  format :json
  default_timeout 15

  def self.all_users
    get('/users')
  end

  def self.find_user(id)
    get("/users/#{id}")
  end

  def self.create_user(user_data)
    post('/users', body: user_data.to_json,
         headers: { 'Content-Type' => 'application/json' })
  end

  def self.update_user(id, user_data)
    put("/users/#{id}", body: user_data.to_json,
        headers: { 'Content-Type' => 'application/json' })
  end
end

# Usage
users = UserService.all_users
user = UserService.find_user(1)
new_user = UserService.create_user({ name: 'John Doe', email: 'john@example.com' })

Class Inheritance Characteristics

Advantages: - Direct method access: No need for self.class prefix - Cleaner syntax: More intuitive method calls - Natural fit: When your class is primarily an HTTP client - Simpler configuration: Base URI and options are set once at the class level

Disadvantages: - Single inheritance: Ruby's single inheritance limits your options - Less flexible: Your class is tightly coupled to HTTParty - Primarily static: Usually used with class methods rather than instances

Advanced Configuration Examples

Module with Instance Configuration

class WeatherClient
  include HTTParty

  def initialize(api_key, location)
    @api_key = api_key
    @location = location

    # Instance-specific configuration
    self.class.base_uri 'https://api.openweathermap.org/data/2.5'
    self.class.default_params appid: @api_key, q: @location
  end

  def current_weather
    self.class.get('/weather')
  end

  def forecast
    self.class.get('/forecast')
  end

  private

  def handle_response(response)
    if response.success?
      response.parsed_response
    else
      raise "API Error: #{response.code} - #{response.message}"
    end
  end
end

Class with Error Handling

class GitHubAPI < HTTParty
  base_uri 'https://api.github.com'
  format :json

  # Custom parser for error handling
  class << self
    def request_with_error_handling(method, path, options = {})
      response = send(method, path, options)

      case response.code
      when 200..299
        response.parsed_response
      when 401
        raise 'Authentication failed'
      when 403
        raise 'Rate limit exceeded'
      when 404
        raise 'Resource not found'
      else
        raise "HTTP Error: #{response.code}"
      end
    end
  end

  def self.user(username)
    request_with_error_handling(:get, "/users/#{username}")
  end

  def self.repositories(username)
    request_with_error_handling(:get, "/users/#{username}/repos")
  end
end

Performance and Memory Considerations

Module Approach Memory Usage

When using HTTParty as a module, each instance of your class will have its own state, but the HTTParty functionality is shared across all instances. This can be more memory-efficient when you need multiple instances with different configurations.

class ScrapingClient
  include HTTParty

  def initialize(proxy_config)
    @proxy_config = proxy_config
    configure_proxy
  end

  private

  def configure_proxy
    self.class.http_proxy(@proxy_config[:host], @proxy_config[:port])
  end
end

# Multiple instances with different proxies
client1 = ScrapingClient.new(host: 'proxy1.com', port: 8080)
client2 = ScrapingClient.new(host: 'proxy2.com', port: 8080)

Class Approach for Singleton Patterns

The class inheritance approach works well for singleton-style API clients where you don't need multiple instances:

class SlackAPI < HTTParty
  base_uri 'https://slack.com/api'

  class << self
    def token=(value)
      headers 'Authorization' => "Bearer #{value}"
    end

    def send_message(channel, text)
      post('/chat.postMessage', body: {
        channel: channel,
        text: text
      })
    end
  end
end

SlackAPI.token = ENV['SLACK_TOKEN']
SlackAPI.send_message('#general', 'Hello from HTTParty!')

Testing Considerations

Testing Module-based Classes

require 'rspec'
require 'webmock/rspec'

RSpec.describe ApiClient do
  let(:api_key) { 'test-key' }
  let(:client) { ApiClient.new(api_key) }

  before do
    stub_request(:get, "https://api.example.com/users/123")
      .to_return(status: 200, body: { id: 123, name: 'Test User' }.to_json)
  end

  it 'fetches user data' do
    response = client.fetch_user(123)
    expect(response.parsed_response['name']).to eq('Test User')
  end
end

Testing Class-based Inheritance

RSpec.describe UserService do
  before do
    stub_request(:get, "https://jsonplaceholder.typicode.com/users/1")
      .to_return(status: 200, body: { id: 1, name: 'John Doe' }.to_json)
  end

  it 'finds a user by ID' do
    user = UserService.find_user(1)
    expect(user['name']).to eq('John Doe')
  end
end

When to Choose Each Approach

Choose Module Inclusion When:

Your class needs to inherit from another class
You need multiple instances with different configurations
Your class handles both HTTP requests and other business logic
You want more control over method visibility and access

Choose Class Inheritance When:

Your class is primarily an HTTP client
You prefer cleaner, more direct method syntax
You're building a simple API wrapper
You don't need complex inheritance hierarchies

Integration with Web Scraping Workflows

Both approaches work well in web scraping scenarios. For complex scraping operations that might benefit from handling browser sessions or managing timeouts effectively, you might combine HTTParty with other tools for comprehensive data extraction workflows.

Best Practices and Recommendations

Use modules for complex domain objects that need HTTP capabilities alongside other functionality
Use inheritance for dedicated API clients that primarily make HTTP requests
Consider thread safety when using class-level configurations with modules
Implement proper error handling regardless of the approach chosen
Test both approaches thoroughly with appropriate mocking strategies

Conclusion

The choice between using HTTParty as a module versus a class depends on your specific use case and architectural preferences. Modules offer more flexibility and work well when HTTP functionality is just one aspect of your class. Class inheritance provides cleaner syntax and is ideal for dedicated HTTP clients. Both approaches are valid and widely used in the Ruby community, so choose based on your project's requirements and design principles.

Understanding these differences will help you make informed decisions about structuring your HTTP client code and building robust web scraping and API integration solutions.

Table of contents